How does the Dramatic Theology Approach to Purgatory Contribute to the Idea of Merciful Justice in the Case of Sexual Abuse in the Church?

  • Yosafat Roni Sentosa University of Innsbruck
Keywords: Merciful Justice, Sexual Abuse, Catholic Church, Dramatic Theology, Purgatory, Restorative Justice, Forgiveness, Reconciliation.

Abstract

In cases of serious and complex sexual abuse, the exercise of mercy raises serious controversies and problems regarding the justice that victims of sexual violence deserve. Merciful justice is the idea that under certain conditions it is justified to exercise mercy to the extent that it does more good than harm and does not cause injustice to the victim. Restorative justice, forgiveness, and reconciliation are conditions that allow for the exercise of merciful justice in cases of sexual abuse. Merciful justice is possible in sexual abuse cases when all three conditions are achieved (through long, complicated, and arduous stages and processes). This article offers the idea that the Dramatic Theology approach to purgatory helps to deepen the idea of merciful justice in specific cases of sexual abuse in the Catholic Church.

Keywords: Merciful Justice, Dramatic Theology, Purgatory, Restorative Justice, Forgiveness, Reconciliation.

References

Diller, Jeanine. 2013. ―Merciful Justice‖, Philosophia: A Global Journal of Philosophy Vol.
41 pages 719–735 (provided by Kooperation E-Medien Österreich - Springer
Compact).
Feinberg, Joel. 1974. ―Noncomparative Justice‖, The Philosophical Review, Vol. 83, No. 3
(297-338), available at https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/2183696.
Kennan, Marie. 2012. Child Sexual Abuse & The Catholic Church: Gender, Power, and
Organizational Culture, Oxford University Press.
Murphy, Jeffrie G. 2009. The Case of Dostoevsky's General: Some Ruminations on Forgiving
the Unforgivable, Oxford Journals - Oxford University Press collaborates with
JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Monis (Source: The
Monist, Vol. 92, No. 4. Forgiveness, pp. 556-582).
Sandler, Willibald. 2023. ―Divine Action and Dramatic Christology: A Rereading of
Raymund Schwager’s Jesus in the Drama of Salvation‖, Journal Religions Vol.
14, (This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and
conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/).
Schwager, Raymund. 1999. Jesus in the Drama of Salvation: Toward a Biblical Doctrine of
Redemption, translated by James G. Williams and Paul Haddon, English
translation by The Crossroad Publishing Company.
———. 2000. Must There Be Scapegoats? Violence and Redemption in the Bible, translated
by Assad, M. L. 2 ed. New York, N. Y.: Crossroad.
Stork, Peter. 2007. ―THE DRAMA OF JESUS AND THE NON-VIOLENT IMAGE OF
GOD: Raymund Schwager’s Approach to the Problem of Divine Violence‖,
Pacifica Australasian Theological Studies, Australian Catholic University,
Canberra, Australia.
Wandinger, Nikolaus. 2023. ―Can Purgatory Help? Reflections from Dramatic Theology in
the Context of the Abuse Crisis‖, in Fleming, D. J., Keenan, J. F. and Zollner,
H. (ed.) Journal of Moral Theology 3.
———. 2003. ―´Denn sie Wissen nicht, was sie tun´: Impulse zum Sünderverständnis aus der
Dramatischen Theologie R. Schwagers‖, in Józef Niewiadomski, Nikolaus
Wandinger (Hg.), Dramatische Theologie im Gespräch, Symposion zum 65.
Geburtstag von Raymund Schwager, Verlag Münster-Hamburg-London, 2003.
———. 2004. ―Dramatic Theology (Its Meaning and Relevance)‖, Presentation given at the
Celebration in Honor of Raymund Schwager during the Conference of the
Colloquium on Violence and Religion at Ghost Ranch, New Mexico, June, 2nd
2004, (Wandinger Nikolaus: Dramatic Theology (uibk.ac.at), accessed on
August 1st, 2024).
———. 2020. ―Gnade oder Gerechtigkeit? Systematisch-theologische Überlegungen im
Anschluss an den Film ―Dead Man Walking―, In: Monika Datterl u.a. (Hg.):
Friede – Gnade – Gerechtigkeit. Im Spannungsfeld zwischen Institutionen und
persönlichem Engagement (theologische trends 30). Innsbruck, pp. 217-235.
———. 2006. ―RAYMUND SCHWAGER, S.J. DRAMATIC THEOLOGY‖, Lonergan
Workshop Vol. 19, University of Innsbruck, Austria.
———. 2017 ―Salvation through Forgiveness or through the Cross? Raymund Schwager’s
Dramatic Solution to a False Alternative‖, in Kirwan, M. and Treflé Hidden, S.
(ed.) Mimesis and Atonement. René Girard and the Doctrine of Salvation
(Violence, Desire, and the Sacred 5), New York, London et al.: Bloomsbury,
95–114.
———. 2016. ―The Rationale behind Purgatory‖, in Georg Gasser (ed.), Personal Identity
and resurrection: How Do We Survive our Death, Routledge: USA.
Wenzel, Michael cum suis. 2007. Retributive and Restorative Justice, Published online: 24
October 2007 American Psychology-Law Society/Division 41 of the American
Psychological Association.
Catechism
III
"The
Final
Purification,
or
Purgatory"
Http://www.vatican.va/content/catechism/en/part_one/section_two/chapter_thr
ee/article_12/iii_the_final_purification,_or_purgatory.html, accessed August
2nd, 2024.
Bible - Catholic Online, Http://www.catholic.org/bible/
Published
2024-10-31
Section
Articles